Ulema & Javed Ahmad Ghamidi: A Clash of Traditional Narrative and Counter Narrative of Deen Question Answer Q&A
**Topics of discussions:------------------------------
What authority you have as deeni scholar? you are not from madarsa? your looks also not like a traditional scholar.
What you have red in Arabic grammer which is compulsory for deen
What you have red in fiqh? from where you have taken your deeni tabeer?
What hadees books you have red
From where you have learned Quran
What have you red in philosophy and how you are rationalizing deen.
----
What you want to do with deen, you want to invent new things in deen? You create your own principle to understand deen, who gave you this right?
You want to understand deen in your own perspective.
Since 1400 yrs only you are able to understand, all other groups are standing against you.
You are creating a new firqa and creating fitna
When you lecture, you say with all certainty, that only your point is correct.
On what certainty you say all such sweeping statements that Quran isse khali hai, hadees isse khali hai...
------
You always make changes in your book, how someone can follow you.
Deen cannot change, other field of knowledge can change, you are moving from taqleed towards takhreeb, you are creating confusion in basics of deen.
Is deen also ilm?
What argument you have for the source of deen.
From hadees you dot take any aqeeda or amal of deen?
You are a Hypocrite, when you says the source of deen is Prophet muhammad but you do not take his hadees.
Do you believe in Taqdeer? this is mentioned in hadees not in Quran. Belief in taqdeer is one of the basic of imaan as per hadees e Jibreel
------
Azam ka fitna, on 7 Qirat of Quran? You believe in Tawattur, then why not 7 Qirat.
Allama Suyuti and Imam Badaruddin have different opinion than you.
You doubt on the protection of Quran. Where they read the other Qirat isn't that Quran?
Abdullah ibn Masood's ravayat that Quran revealed in 7 huroof
Raavi of Qiraat e amma is also azmi
Anyone else also declined akhbaare ahaad other than farahi school?
When the continuity of Quran's status broke?
-----------
Islamic state, would have given you very high punishment, you have different translation of Quran, Surah Ikhlas and Surah Alaa
You do not stick to your own created principle, you take a different approach from well known meaning of Arabic words.
You criticize taqleed and you yourself follow your school of thought fully.
You have a difference of opinion just for the sake of having a difference.
---------
Your 25/30 yrs analysis is different from 1400 yrs of Islamic traditions, why only you got this knowledge.
You understand Islamic knowledge on Daleel, was not this the case of earlier scholars?
You think of yourself big, other scholar were more humble than to adopt a different approach.
You challenge 'wahy' and did other scholars were not having intellect and only Farahi school got this wisdom.
you are creating fitna, this is all your rational thoughts and you contest wahy with this, challenge wahy by your aql??
You are opening door for everyone to have his own view and daleel
We should present quran rather than daleel/intellect
You dont believe but try to understand deen & wahy
You believe half and reject half as per your convenience
-----------

You defined sunnah in a new way, you use words different from its well known meanings.
Why number of Sunnah changes in your analysis, if something is definite, why there is not a definite count of it in your lectures
----------
Why Ghamidi Sb, have harsh views on some Sahaba, accusing them of Fasaad fil Ardh.
Ghamidi Sb you have different views on Haz 'Isa Alaihissalaam' coming back to world, opposite to Quran and Hadees.
------------
You say, we cannot call anybody Mushrik or Kafir, it is beyond humans to declare such, any individual or a group.
------
You say only 4 things in food is haram, how is it?
You are very liberal in issues related to haya, and woman and man meeting etiquette
your people are not visible in favor of Muslims
your talks and books, does not increase khashiat in me


Al-Mawrid Website: http://www.al-mawrid.org
Al-Mawrid Hind Website: http://www.almawridindia.org
E-Mail: [email protected], [email protected]
Facebook:   / almawridhind  
Subscribe:    / almawridhind  
Twitter:   / almawridindia  
Instagram:   / almawridhindfoundation  

Key Words:
Islam
Quran
Allah
Hadith
Muhammad
Javed Ahmad Ghamidi


#Islam #JavedAhmadGhamidi